Bill Morris: March 2011

Austin Permits and Construction -- signs for the future?

Volatile.  Unpredictable.  Erratic.  I have used all those adjectives to describe market conditions for Austin/Central Texas residential real estate over the past few months.  They all apply, and 2011 will call for ongoing analysis and forecasting.  New construction and newly issued building permits should give us a glimpse at the future, however.  I commented earlier this week on recent home price trends, so this seems a natural place to continue thinking about what 2011 holds for the Austin area.

First, let's consider recent sales of single family residential properties (houses, condos, townhouses, and lofts).  I have commented frequently about this segment of the market, so as a point of reference consider this view of all residential sales since 2005:

Austin Sales and Pricing

My Austin Market Dashboard discusses this in considerable detail, but for the purposes of this post, suffice it to say that unit volume is down substantially since the market peak, but home values have remained surprisingly stable -- even appreciating through most of the recession.

Sales of new homes also slowed.  This chart shows activity over the past two years:

Residential Sales 02/2009 - 02/2011
New Home Sales 02/2009 - 02/2011

Again, home values held relatively stable, but unit volume is obviously down, especially since the end of the last homebuyer tax incentive program last June 30.

Turning to multifamily properties, new construction virtually stopped in recent years:

Multifamily New Construction 03/2006 - 03/2011

That chart shows a total of 85 new multifamily properties sold in the past five years -- 82 duplexes and 3 fourplexes.  (New apartments are not typically built for immediate sale, and in the rare situation where that happens the sale would not be reported in our MLS.)  Obviously, smaller investors have had little appetite for new construction.  Over the past two years, that was even more true:

Multifamily New Construction 02/2009 - 02/2011

Yes, you see that correctly: a total of six new multifamily structures -- 3 duplexes and 3 fourplexes -- were sold in the past two years.  There have been no sales in this segment in the past nine months.

Building permits seem to predict a somewhat different future -- or at least show builders' and investors' confidence in a different future:

Building Permits 02/2010 - 02/2011

Note that this chart includes 5+ Family properties -- apartments -- and that is where we find the most impressive feature:  Permits issued just in November 2010 through January 2011 totaled more than 80% of all permits issued in the entire year 2010.  This sector had been so slow earlier in the year that this late surge only brought the 12-month total up to 78% of permits issued in 2009, but it does represent renewed confidence in the rental market 2012 and beyond.

Somewhat shorter term, there was also an impressive surge in permits issued for 2-4 Family properties -- 302 dwelling units approved in the past twelve months, compared to 31 in all of 2009.  That's a 974% increase!

Construction of single family dwelling units -- houses, condos, townhouses, and lofts -- will remain slow this year:  Permits issued over the past 12 months represent only 89% of the total issued in 2009.  In this case, the local housing market will be well served by this conservatism.  It will allow resale activity to absorb most demand and support stronger resale values than if builders were aggressively adding inventory.

We do not see across the board optimism for the Austin/Central Texas residential market in these figures, and given the uncertainties presented by the national economy that makes sense.  I have noted before that the Austin area continues to enjoy growth in population and jobs, but home purchases by those newcomers may well be delayed by their inability to sell homes elsewhere (or reluctance to sell at the reduced values that many markets have seen).  Even more who could buy may simply choose to avoid homeownership until they see a clearer economic future.  These trends should begin to correct later this year and growth should gain momentum in 2012 and beyond, but in the short run new Austinites in those situations will be renters.

That is what this data shows:  Confidence that there will be demand over the next couple of years for a larger supply of rental homes -- apartments and smaller multifamily properties.  Building permits should lead to construction starts and property sales in those sectors.  The coming months will show whether investors' confidence is well-placed at this time.  Assuming that they are right, then renewed single family construction will follow and our next market growth cycle will begin in earnest next year.

Bill F. Morris, ABR, CRS, CDPE, e-PRO, MBA
RE/MAX Capital City
Call or Text:       512-785-3345
Toll-Free:           1-800-692-8784, x 162

Your personal referrals are the best measure of my success!

Comment balloon 0 commentsBill Morris • March 30 2011 06:56PM
Austin Permits and Construction -- signs for the future?
Volatile. Unpredictable. Erratic. I have used all those adjectives to describe market conditions for Austin/Central Texas residential real estate over the past few months. They all apply, and 2011 will call for ongoing… more
Austin and Case-Shiller - moving the same direction?
Yet another update of S&P's Case-Shiller Home Price Index provided news going into the Spring/Summer selling season that will be discouraging to homeowners who want or need to sell soon, and good news for prospective home buyers:&… more
Austin Real Estate Market Dashboard
My Market Dashboard is a compilation of many key measures of market health that I began studying a few years ago and have found valuable in explaining circumstances in the Austin-area real estate market compared to news we have all… more
Hedge fund manager against home ownership. Really?
This post appeared yesterday on Yahoo! Finance: Why I Am Never Going to Own a Home Again The writer and interviewee is James Altucher, managing director of Formula Capital. I have done some brief research on Mr. Altrucher and his company… more
Investors: Time to get in, in Austin
Austin has weathered the housing downturn much better than most of the United States, but not all market segments are rosy. All real estate is hyper-local, with market conditions varying widely from one neighborhood to another, even… more
Sales and Prices -- Austin compared
A few weeks ago the National Association of Realtors® reported: Existing-Home Sales Rise Again in January <! -- WebTrends Script End--> (02/23/2011). Among the available supporting data were comparisons of single family home sales -… more
Growth in multifamily building -- a good sign
A couple of weeks ago I wrote about the strength and optimism of the multifamily residential market in the Austin/Central Texas market: A strong sign of confidence in multi-family properties I promised to keep an eye on this and report… more
2010 Job Growth in Austin
Opportunity Austin, an economic development arm of the Austin Chamber of Commerce published its 2010 Annual Report today. Introductory comments include this: "Austin has topped countless national rankings for job… more
Great expectations among Texas manufacturers
The Austin Chamber of Commerce posted an interesting report today based on the Texas Manufacturing Outlook Survey: Central Texas Economy in Perspective The outlook is optimistic. I want to comment on just a couple of charts … more
Austin leads the recovery!
Throughout the recession and housing downturn, I have written about the difference in the Austin/Central Texas experience and press reports about nationwide hardships. Now, in less than four minutes, here is a great summary. .. more