Bill Morris: Texas

Case-Shiller today - and Austin

I have elaborated before about the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index and how representative it is (or not) of conditions in the Austin/Central Texas real estate market. (Most recent comments: Case-Shiller caution -- national index, local business, 12/03/10; Quick comparison -- Austin vs. Case-Shiller Index, 01/26/11; and Housing Bubble? Austin compared to Case-Shiller cities, 01/30/11) I will not repeat all of that discussion except to point out that the list of Case-Shiller Index cities is dominated by those that experienced the boom-and-bust of this market cycle most dramatically -- the highest highs and the steepest falls. With that as context, I offer this comparison of Austin home prices with the Case-Shiller Index as reported today:

Austin-Dallas-Case Shiller Comparison 022211

As before, I have not tried to duplicate S&P's methodology. Instead, I have simply "zero'd" a graph of Austin Average Sale Prices at January 2000, and added a 12-month moving average for comparison to the indices shown.

Most discussion of the housing downturn focuses on how much value has been lost in real estate in recent years. That, combined with some very "creative" mortgage financing that facilitated -- maybe even caused -- the housing bubble, is important, especially for those in California, Arizona, Nevada, and Florida who purchased homes near the market peak.

That perspective, however, ignores how much value was created during the boom: On average, if you bought real estate in 2004 and experienced the same appreciation as the 10-City Composite Index, you gained about 37.5% in value by January 2006. If you made a 20% down payment to make that purchase then your leveraged return was actually 187.5%. How many investments can offer the potential to almost triple your money in two years?

Yes, for all the financial devastation during the recession, there were huge fortunes made during those years in the cities that are now suffering the most, but on average homeowners who purchased in those cities before 2004 and are still holding their properties are still fine. If they bought in 2000, they have still gained substantially more in market appreciation than Dallas or Austin.

The Dallas market has been pretty tame throughout the cycle. Dallas property owners did not see the incredible run-up, so the downturn wasn't nearly so painful. That is even more true in Austin, where our 12-month average sale price reached an all-time high in December 2010.

Is there uncertainty still ahead? Absolutely (see my Austin Market Dashboard), but virtually all indicators call for continued improvement in the Austin market. It won't be a straight line, but I agree with the forecasts, and I believe we will see real, predictable growth by 2012.

Bill F. Morris, ABR, CRS, CDPE, e-PRO, MBA
RE/MAX Capital City
Call or Text:       512-785-3345
Toll-Free:           1-800-692-8784, x 162

Your personal referrals are the best measure of my success!

Comment balloon 1 commentBill Morris • February 22 2011 02:16PM
Case-Shiller today - and Austin
I have elaborated before about the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index and how representative it is (or not) of conditions in the Austin/Central Texas real estate market. (Most recent comments: Case-Shiller caution -- national index,… more
A quick comparison -- my Dashboard and new Austin Board report
The Austin Board Of Realtors® reported yesterday that "Sales of single-family homes in the Austin area were 14 percent higher in January 2011 than January 2010. " (See Austin Business Journal article ) Since that data… more
Updated Austin Market Dashboard
This is just a quick note that my Austin Market Dashboard has now been updated to include final data through January 2011. The theme this month is that the Austin/Central Texas real estate market remains unpredictable -- although… more
Texas cities' financial performance
The Greater Austin Chamber Of Commerce posted some very interesting information this week about Texas and our major metro areas, and their relative performance economically. The article points out that the Texas Index of Leading… more
Romance in Austin and Round Rock..
Here are a couple of new "top" rankings for Austin and Central Texas -- one that is beyond doubt, and another that I'll just have to trust. There is SOOOO much to do in Austin that Vavoom. com ranks us 2nd, behind only Miami: .. more
Austin building permits and market outlook
Earlier this week I posted on AustinMarketInfo. com an article from the Greater Austin Chamber Of Commerce reporting on residential building permits in the Austin area, and nationally: Central Texas Economy in Perspective It's… more
Austin rental market, investment properties
For market watchers in Austin and Central Texas this trend has been visible, but the Austin American-Statesman made it public information over the weekend: Apartment market rebound good news for landlords, but tenants face higher rents … more
Price it right, don't waste time and money
Preparation, staging, marketing, follow-up, sales, negotiation… There are many things that an experienced real estate professional can and should do when representing a home seller. Comprehensive market analysis… more
Rental properties in Austin -- where to invest?
There are many ways to evaluate income-producing properties -- cash flow, cash-on-cash return, equity rate of return, net present value analysis or internal rate of return, and others. They all have their place in investment… more
A few Austin employment success stories
It's one thing to cite statistics about the strength of Texas and the Austin economy and job growth as I have frequently, including this post last week: Growth and employment in Austin It's another thing to discuss specific… more